In my experience, the ability to deliver difficult, high-stakes feedback cleanly is the single greatest sign of executive maturity. Most leaders fear this process because they dread the emotional fallout. As a result, they deliver sugar-coated truth or ambiguous critique, which is unfair to the person and toxic to the culture.
The solution is structure. Use the Four-Step Conversation Arc to move from problem to solution with clarity and compassion.
The Four-Step Conversation Arc:
The Anchor (Rapport and Intent): Start by anchoring the recipient in their value and the core intent of the conversation. “We are having this conversation because your success is vital to the strategy, and I need you to operate at your full potential. My intent is to help you achieve that.” This immediately lowers the emotional shield and establishes the conversation as a support mechanism, not an attack.
The Data (The What): State the observable data without emotional language. Use the most objective, undeniable evidence. Do not generalise. Weak: "You were unprofessional last week." Strong: "In the meeting on Tuesday, you interrupted the CFO three times while they were presenting the Q3 numbers." Keep the data isolated from your interpretation.
The Impact (The Why): This is the most crucial step. Explain the strategic consequence of their action, not the personal frustration it caused you. Weak: "It makes me look bad." Strong: "Interrupting the CFO created the perception among the committee that we lack unified governance, which compromised our ability to secure the necessary funding for Q4." Connect their behaviour to the Cathedral (the strategy).
The Path Forward (The How): This must be a co-created solution, not a mandated directive. State the required change in behaviour and ask them to propose the strategy to close the gap. “The required change is to allow all key stakeholders to finish their presentations before providing commentary. What is the process or support you need from me to ensure this happens in the next three weeks?”
Following this arc ensures you eliminate ambush, establish shared intent, and focus the energy on solvable behaviour rather than fixed personality. The highest compliment an executive can receive after a hard conversation is: "Thank you for the clarity."
Former senior leader in a FTSE100 organisation, now executive coach specialising in leadership transformation through mindset, NLP, and hypnosis. I help leaders access clarity, confidence, and impact by mastering their state and energy. My role is not to give answers, but to unlock the resourcefulness already within you.
Insights for decisive leaders.
Practical ideas on self-leadership, presence and performance, field-tested with real teams.
Sign up to receive new insights straight to your inbox.
